Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Pennsylvania weighs in

A State Finds No Easy Fixes on Health Care - Gov. Edward G. Rendell of Pennsylvania wants health coverage for the 900,000 people who lack it. source: New York Times

First some facts:

  • 900,000 Pennsylvanians are uninsured
  • 6.5% of health-insurance premiums went to subsidizing care for the uninsured
  • 19,154 cases of hospital-acquired infections in 2005 in Pennsylvania resulting in 400,000 additional patient days in the hospital and $3.5 billion in charges
  • 175 hospital medical errors over a 30-month period, many classified as “wrong-site surgeries
Covering the uninsured means hospitals cutting costs. PA Governor Rendell's plan would require hospitals to adopt hygiene practices to reduce infection rates, i.e., more hand-washing. To manage chronic diseases more efficiently in a state with a large elderly population, the plan would give incentives to providers who encourage healthier lifestyles and closer attention to medications.

The governor of Illinois says that savings generated by better management of chronic diseases and expanded use of electronic records will exceed the cost of extending coverage to 1.4 million adults.

Hospitals, doctors, insurers and small businesses all reject the PA governors proposals
  • Hospitals don't want to lose reimbursements when patient stays are extended because of medical mistakes and preventable infections.
  • Doctors do not like the idea of giving more responsibility to physicians’ assistants and nurse midwives.
  • Insurers reject proposals that would prohibit them from considering preexisitng conditions in setting rates and requiring that at least 85 percent of premiums be spent on health care costs as opposed to administrative costs.
  • Businesses don't want to pay a 3% payroll tax on employers who do not offer insurance

Hospitals don't want to go out of their way to take better care of patients. Shouldn't hospitals put in every effort to avoid making us sicker? Insurers don't want to cut into their profits. How about a proposal where we cut out insurers? How is it that we have such a high tolerance for such selfishness and greed, especially when lives are at stake?

No comments: